Via Cuma - Sourdough Pizza & Cucina

Best neopolitan pizza on Long Island hands down. Luca, Ivan and the crew are the greatest guys. Italian passion on full display. From the minute you walk in to your last bite you are in Italy ????????. Eat here, you will not be disappointed.

- Lawrence Galiano -

This was my first time going into the restaurant and for me and my partner it did not disappoint. The food was tasty with normal and filling portion sizes worth all the money. I loved Ivan, he knows his stuff. He was very professional and charismatic, giving us a great 10/10 experience i just wished he had more help while we where there. I tried the awesome Parmigiana di Melanzane and next time i will try your pizzas they looked delicious as well. I recommend the tiramisu for the dessert which was delicate of flavors my partner could not get enough.

- Maria F -

Via Cuma has been the absolute best addition to the Valley Stream Area! You walk in and you instantly feel like you are in Italy! The food is absolutely amazing and always fresh! They use the best quality products imported from Italy! You can't get better than that! We have been customers since day 1 and always look forward to going back. Luca and Ivan are amazing people that have become good friends of our family. This restaurant is amazing. Please go try it and thank me later! ????????????????

- Joann Cioffi -

A place that has many regulars is a healthy sign indeed. I needed a place to get good pizza on the way home from work and stumbled across an Italian pizza place 4 minutes down the road in Valley Stream… now recognized as one of the top 10 pizzerias in Long Island. Regulars come in and chat with Ivan and with Luca. Spoilt for choices as far as pizza went, I enjoyed the Buffala with a glass of non-alcoholic wine: a first for me. (You can BYOB). The pizza was excellent - truly good ingredients, as well as warm and conversational service. For next time: I’ll have to stay for dessert.

- Willy Kane -

From start to finish, this hidden gem absolutely exceeded expectations. The food was exceptional — every dish was beautifully presented, perfectly seasoned, and bursting with fresh flavor. You can tell the chef takes real pride in their craft. But what truly made the experience unforgettable was the service. The staff went above and beyond — attentive without being intrusive, warm, professional, and genuinely welcoming. They anticipated our needs before we even had to ask and made us feel like valued guests throughout the meal. It’s rare to find a place that delivers both incredible food and even better service, but this restaurant does it effortlessly. Whether we are looking to enjoy a delicious dinner or simply popping in for coffee and dessert, we highly recommend to anyone looking for a top-tier dining experience!

- Kimberly Coral -

If you’re craving a true taste of Italy in New York, this is the place to go! It’s a fantastic spot serving authentic Italian cuisine. The owner is incredibly friendly, and the food is always fresh and delicious. Whether you’re looking for a new date-night spot or a place to enjoy dinner with the family, I highly recommend it. If you’ve been to Italy and miss authentic pizza, you’ll find that familiar flavor here. And if you’ve never experienced real Italian cuisine, this is the perfect place to discover what you’ve been missing.

- Timothy Mojica -

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ First time here and it was awesome! We started with the alici appetizer, then had a Quattro Formaggi con Prosciutto pizza and a Bufala pizza — both were incredible. The crust was light, chewy, and had that real Napoli-style flavor and texture. We finished with the Tiramisù in the mocha pot, which was super tasty and such a cool touch. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Can’t wait to come back!

- Dillon -

Amazing place. They have it all. Food, Service, Ambiance. The owner and head waiter are extremely welcoming, attentive, and engaging during the entire meal. As vegetarians, we had plenty of options but went with the eggplant parm appetizer, classic Margherita pizza, Buffala Filetto pizza, and the tiramisu. All were perfect. Their sourdough crust has the perfect balance of crisp, crunch, and chew yet light and airy. Nonna's tiramisu is better than the best in Rome! I emplore you to please open your second branch in Huntington!

- Kamal Dagly -